Improving Decision Making: Deviation from the Expected(Value)

By Matt Curtis
Oct 12, 2023

Individuals, organizations, and societies must make choices every day. Often, when making decisions, people gravitate towards the allure of a single, "most-likely" outcome that offers a sense of comfort and certainty. However, this comfort can be misleading, as the real world is complex and uncertain. Even the most well-informed and well-intentioned decisions can lead to unfavorable outcomes due to unforeseen variables and variance in the outcomes.

Leaders should conceptualize decision-making through the lens of an Expected Value Framework, emphasizing the importance of reckoning with the possibility of five distinct outcomes: expected, better than expected, less than expected, best possible outcome, and worst possible outcome. This framework encourages decision-makers to embrace uncertainty, enabling them to make more informed, rational, and resilient decisions.

Embracing Uncertainty

The Expected Value Framework compels decision-makers to confront the full range of possible outcomes, encouraging them to be proactive and adaptable. Instead of seeking the illusion of certainty, they are prompted to assess risks, make informed choices, and strategize for both favorable and unfavorable scenarios.

By calculating the EV, decision-makers assign a numerical value to their choices, taking into account the likelihood of different outcomes. This allows for more rigorous decision analysis and prioritizes actions that maximize the expected value over those that merely offer the illusion of comfort.  

The Expected Value Framework

The Expected Value (EV) Framework is a mathematical concept that calculates the value of a decision by considering the probability of different outcomes and the corresponding values associated with each outcome. It is a versatile tool for decision-makers to assess the potential impact of their choices and to incorporate risk management into their decision-making process.

Expected Outcome: The "expected" outcome represents the most probable result of a decision based on available information. This is the outcome that aligns with the conventional "most-likely" scenario. Decision-makers often use this as a baseline for evaluating their choices.

Better Than Expected: In reality, outcomes can be better than what was initially expected. Decision-makers should recognize that a favorable outcome is possible, and they should strive to maximize the likelihood of achieving such outcomes through informed decision-making.

Less Than Expected: Conversely, outcomes can also be less favorable than anticipated. Acknowledging this possibility allows decision-makers to be prepared for setbacks and adjust their strategies, accordingly, fostering adaptability and resilience.

Best Possible Outcome: This represents the ideal outcome—the best-case scenario. While achieving this outcome may be rare, it is crucial to aim for it when possible. Decision-makers can identify strategies and actions that increase the probability of reaching this optimal result.

Worst Possible Outcome: On the other end of the spectrum is the worst-case scenario. By recognizing the potential for catastrophic outcomes, decision-makers can implement risk mitigation measures to minimize the likelihood of these adverse events.

Combating Down-side Risk

Implementing the Expected Value Framework within decision-making processes not only quantifies potential outcomes but also compels leaders to vividly imagine the possibility of different results. By acknowledging and assigning probabilities to better, worse, best, and worst-case scenarios, leaders are prompted to delve into the intricacies of their decisions. This imaginative exercise allows them to anticipate challenges, devise contingency plans, and strategize for how to counteract some of the downside possibilities. It fosters a proactive approach to risk management, encouraging leaders to identify early warning signs and implement measures that can mitigate or address unfavorable outcomes. In doing so, leaders can effectively steer their organizations through uncertainty, ensuring that they are prepared to adapt and thrive in a rapidly changing world.  

Decision-makers should view an Expected Value Framework as a guiding principle in their decision-making process. By acknowledging the five distinct outcomes—expected, better than expected, less than expected, best possible, and worst possible—they become better equipped to navigate the complexities of a dynamic world. Embracing uncertainty and employing the EV Framework enables individuals and organizations to make rational, resilient decisions that account for the true nature of the unpredictable and multifaceted reality we live in. Ultimately, it empowers decision-makers to move beyond the allure of false certainty and towards a more informed, adaptable, and successful future.

Hungry for more?

Discover more ideas to improve your business

Beyond the Numbers: The Power of Benchmarking

Discover benchmarking's true potential as a guiding beacon for improvement and transformation. This essay unveils the often misunderstood nuances of benchmarking, emphasizing that it's more than just chasing numbers. It's about understanding context, improving the entire ecosystem, and broadening your perspective to decipher the complex web of business influences.

Getting Started With GenAI: Your Employees Already Have...

Adoption of Generative AI is on the rise, executive leadership must prioritize understanding, assessing, and responsibly implementing generative AI within organizations. Learn how to bridge skill gaps, create usage guidelines, and foster a culture of ethical exploration and continuous learning to unlock the full potential of this transformative technology.

Building Better KPIs: Costuming KPIs for the Audience

Discover how speaking stakeholders' language enhances KPI implementation, fostering informed decision-making in digital transformation and analytics for SMBs.

Book a Meeting & Find Balance with a Digital Transformation
Let's make your vision a reality
Bring harmony to your business
Start Now